• HOME
  • ABOUT ME
  • WORK WITH ME
    • COACHING PROGRAMS
    • PRODUCTS
  • BLOG
    • DATING BLOG
    • SEX, LOVE, & MINDFUL DATING PODCAST
    • WORLD’S GREATEST LOVE STORIES PODCAST
  • DATING MEDIA INTERVIEWS
  • TESTIMONIALS

Amie Leadingham - Amie the Dating Coach | Master Certified Relationship Coach | Online Dating Expert | Author

  • HOME
  • ABOUT ME
  • WORK WITH ME
    • COACHING PROGRAMS
    • PRODUCTS
  • BLOG
    • DATING BLOG
    • SEX, LOVE, & MINDFUL DATING PODCAST
    • WORLD’S GREATEST LOVE STORIES PODCAST
  • DATING MEDIA INTERVIEWS
  • TESTIMONIALS
Blog / dating / dating questions / Dating Tips / Find Love / First Dates / Law of Attraction / Online Dating / Red Flags / Relationships / Self Esteem

How and When to Ask Someone Out from a Dating App

Let’s be honest…navigating those early messaging stages in online dating often feels like trying to solve a puzzle with missing pieces. “When should I suggest meeting up?” “What’s the perfect way to ask?” I’m here to clear something up that might surprise you: in today’s digital dating landscape, those traditional gender roles about who asks who out? They simply don’t apply during these initial online exchanges.

The universal goal, regardless of your gender, is to move from those back-and-forth messages to an actual face-to-face connection where chemistry can truly be tested. It’s only after that first meetup that the more traditional dating dynamics tend to emerge.

Today, I’m sharing my proven approach to moving from those first digital messages to meaningful in-person connections.

Stage 1: The Opening Connection (Days 1-3)

The opening message sets the tone for everything that follows. One of my clients had been sending generic “Hey, how’s it going?” messages for months with minimal response.

When he switched to referencing specific profile details, his response rate doubled overnight. Skip the generic opener and show you’ve actually read their profile.

The key is to reference something specific that caught your attention and ask an open-ended question that invites conversation, not just a yes or no answer. Keep it light, genuine, and relatively brief—two or three sentences are perfect.

Try something like: “I noticed we both love [shared interest]. What first got you into that?”

Another similar approach works well: “Your enthusiasm for [something from their profile] really caught my attention. What’s your favorite aspect of it?”

Conscious Dating is about building a genuine curiosity rather than appearance-based compliments. The goal is to seek to build an emotional connection through shared interests or values, not just physical attraction.

Stage 2: Building Rapport (Days 3-5)

Once initial messages have been exchanged, it’s time to deepen the conversation and establish some real connection. I remember coaching a client who kept conversations fun but superficial, wondering why her connections fizzled after a week.

The breakthrough came when she began gently steering chats toward values and experiences rather than just hobbies and entertainment.

Look for opportunities to transition from surface-level topics to more meaningful exchanges. You might say something like: “I’ve really enjoyed our chat about [topic]. I’d love to hear more about your perspective on [related deeper topic].”

Or: “I appreciate how thoughtful you are about [observation from conversation]. It makes me curious about your approach to [slightly deeper topic].”

Or: “The way you described [something they shared] resonates with me because [brief personal connection]. What other values are important to you?”

In this stage of Conscious Dating, we’re gradually increasing disclosure while watching for reciprocity. You’re looking for someone who matches your energy and depth—not pushing for premature intimacy or keeping things perpetually surface-level.

Learn the 5 Toxic Online Dating Behaviors to Avoid in this video. 

Stage 3: Moving to Voice/Video (Days 5-7)

After establishing good text rapport with consistent exchanges, suggesting a phone or video call helps verify chemistry and connection before meeting in person. This step is crucial for saving time and confirming mutual interest.

Take one client’s experience: after two weeks of delightful texting with a match who seemed perfect on paper, their first phone call revealed a critical disconnect in communication styles that wouldn’t have been evident through text alone. That 20-minute call saved her efforts of further investment in someone ultimately incompatible.

To transition to this stage, try saying: “I’ve really enjoyed our conversations here. Would you be open to a quick phone/video chat this week? I find it’s a nice way to continue getting to know each other.“

Or: “These messages have been the highlight of my day! I’d love to hear your voice—maybe a 20-minute call this weekend if you’re comfortable with that?”

A straightforward approach works well: “I’m enjoying getting to know you, and I find that a quick video chat can tell us so much more than texting. Would you be up for that sometime this week?”

Or: “I’ve really valued our conversations and would love to continue them in a more direct way. Would you be comfortable with a short phone call in the next few days?”

The Conscious Dating approach here includes suggesting a specific timeframe and providing an easy out. We’re being respectfully assertive without pressure. If someone is hesitant about this step, honor that while being honest about your own dating process.

Stage 4: Planning the First Meeting (Days 7-10)

After a successful call that confirms your interest, it’s time to suggest meeting in person. I still smile thinking about a client who was so nervous about suggesting a first meeting that he sent a paragraph-long message with three different date options, two backup plans, and assurances that “no pressure at all!”

His match later told him she almost declined simply because his approach seemed so anxious. When he simplified to a specific, confident suggestion, his success rate soared.

Be specific when making this suggestion, as it makes it easier for the other person to say yes.

You might say: “I really enjoyed our conversation yesterday! I’d love to continue it in person. Would you be interested in meeting for [specific activity] this weekend?”

You might try: “Our conversation last night made me smile. I’d enjoy continuing it over coffee at [specific place] this Saturday afternoon if you’re available.”

Or you could use: “I’ve really enjoyed getting to know you these past couple of weeks. Would you like to meet for a walk at [specific park] or coffee at [specific café] this weekend?”

When planning the first meeting, keep these Conscious Dating tips in mind:

  • Choose a public location where you both feel comfortable
  • Suggest a specific activity, place, and time
  • Keep it relatively brief (1 hour) – Coffee shop or drinks.
  • Plan for a natural end time but leave room to extend if things are going well
  • Focus on positive conversation-friendly activities where you can actually talk

Finding Your Dating Rhythm

While I’ve provided a general timeline, remember that there’s no perfect formula. Some connections naturally progress faster, while others need more time.

I’ve worked with plenty of Conscious Daters who needed longer than average to feel comfortable meeting in person, and that patience often paid off in more meaningful connections.

The key indicators to watch for are consistent communication with roughly equal effort, increasing disclosure of vulnerability as you gradually share more meaningful information, clear expressions of interest, responsive engagement, and comfort with each new step in the progression.

The Conscious Dating wisdom here is to focus on a positive direction rather than rushing to judgment.

Ask yourself: Is each conversation a little more engaging? Do you feel increasingly comfortable sharing more of yourself? That progression matters more than arbitrary timelines.

As you navigate this process, stay aware of potential red flags:

  • Reluctance to progress beyond text after a reasonable time
  • Inconsistent communication patterns with no explanation
  • Avoidance of personal questions while asking many of you
  • Dismissive responses to your expressed boundaries or preferences

Understanding these messaging stages is just one piece of a conscious approach to finding a meaningful connection. You have to ask yourself, are you truly prepared for the relationship you desire?

Schedule Your Free Relationship Readiness Review with me here! I offer a complimentary 30-minute session to help you identify blind spots in your current approach, clarify what you truly need in a relationship, and develop a personalized strategy for finding your conscious connection.

 

0 Comments
Share
Join the Convo

Leave a Comment Cancel Comment

related posts

You May Also Like

Is it Love or Lust? Five Ways to Tell if Your Relationship is the Real Deal

February 19, 2018

3 Conversation Starters That Spark Intimacy

July 22, 2020

How to Handle Rejection Like a Boss

September 8, 2020

Search Blog Topic

Recent Blog Posts

  • 5 Signs Someone Really Likes You
  • How and When to Ask Someone Out from a Dating App
  • Five Qualities That Make You More Attractive
  • Why Too Much Empathy Can Destroy You: 5 Signs and How to Stop It
  • Overcome the Fear of Abandonment in a Relationship
  • Top 3 Dating Apps for a Serious Relationship
  • Why You Attract Avoidant Partners Who Pull Away (And How to Stop)
  • How to be Vulnerable with Someone You Just Started Dating
  • How to Avoid Getting Stuck in Situationships
  • Dating with Herpes: Finding Love and Self-Acceptance

Instagram

Misunderstandings will happen. Conflict will happen. That’s part of being human. You can explain yourself, open your heart, and speak your truth but you can’t control how others receive it. If someone chooses to walk away even after you’ve tried to explain yourself... let them. 

Their departure isn’t your failure…it’s their choice. Your peace isn’t found in making everyone understand you; it’s in knowing you showed up authentically. Some doors are meant to close so better ones can open. Trust the process. Trust yourself. 

#LetThemTheory #PersonalGrowth #Boundaries #SelfLove​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​
amiethedatingcoach
amiethedatingcoach
•
Follow
Misunderstandings will happen. Conflict will happen. That’s part of being human. You can explain yourself, open your heart, and speak your truth but you can’t control how others receive it. If someone chooses to walk away even after you’ve tried to explain yourself... let them. Their departure isn’t your failure…it’s their choice. Your peace isn’t found in making everyone understand you; it’s in knowing you showed up authentically. Some doors are meant to close so better ones can open. Trust the process. Trust yourself. #LetThemTheory #PersonalGrowth #Boundaries #SelfLove​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​
3 days ago
View on Instagram |
1/5
✨ A day late but the love is just as strong! Happy Mother's Day to my beautiful mom! ✨

Couldn’t let today pass without shouting out the woman who’s been my rock through it all. Thanks for always believing in me, even when I didn’t believe in myself.

Your wisdom, your laugh, your incredible strength – you amaze me every day. So blessed to call you Mom.

Love you beyond words! ❤️

#HappyMothersDay #BestMomEver #Blessed #FamilyFirst​​​​​
amiethedatingcoach
amiethedatingcoach
•
Follow
✨ A day late but the love is just as strong! Happy Mother's Day to my beautiful mom! ✨ Couldn’t let today pass without shouting out the woman who’s been my rock through it all. Thanks for always believing in me, even when I didn’t believe in myself. Your wisdom, your laugh, your incredible strength – you amaze me every day. So blessed to call you Mom. Love you beyond words! ❤️ #HappyMothersDay #BestMomEver #Blessed #FamilyFirst​​​​​
2 weeks ago
View on Instagram |
2/5
Speak Up to Express Your Needs! Ever notice how waiting for “the right time” to express your needs often means they never get addressed? I share my journey of realizing that while we should avoid conversations when emotions are flooding, consistently postponing our needs leads to dangerous resentment. 

Learn the balance between giving space during heightened emotions and still honoring your boundaries through calm, intentional conflict. Discover how speaking up prevents resentment while still respecting emotional states—a critical skill for healthier relationships.

#RelationshipAdvice #HealthyBoundaries #ExpressingNeeds #EmotionalRegulation #PreventingResentment #HealthyConflict #RelationshipCommunication #EmotionalIntelligence #SettingBoundaries #ConflictResolution #RelationshipTips #EmotionalFlooding #PersonalGrowth #RelationshipPsychology #CalmDiscussions #AvoidingResentment #HealthyArguing #RelationshipHealing #CommunicationSkills #EmotionalAwareness
amiethedatingcoach
amiethedatingcoach
•
Follow
Speak Up to Express Your Needs! Ever notice how waiting for “the right time” to express your needs often means they never get addressed? I share my journey of realizing that while we should avoid conversations when emotions are flooding, consistently postponing our needs leads to dangerous resentment. Learn the balance between giving space during heightened emotions and still honoring your boundaries through calm, intentional conflict. Discover how speaking up prevents resentment while still respecting emotional states—a critical skill for healthier relationships. #RelationshipAdvice #HealthyBoundaries #ExpressingNeeds #EmotionalRegulation #PreventingResentment #HealthyConflict #RelationshipCommunication #EmotionalIntelligence #SettingBoundaries #ConflictResolution #RelationshipTips #EmotionalFlooding #PersonalGrowth #RelationshipPsychology #CalmDiscussions #AvoidingResentment #HealthyArguing #RelationshipHealing #CommunicationSkills #EmotionalAwareness
2 weeks ago
View on Instagram |
3/5
When we truly become still and listen to understand others, something magical happens. By setting aside our mental chatter and focusing completely on what someone else is saying, we create a space of genuine connection.

Active listening isn’t just waiting for your turn to speak. It’s being fully present—noticing not just their words, but their tone, their body language, what remains unsaid. When we listen this deeply to others, we’re actually strengthening our ability to tune into our own inner voice.

Think about it: each time you quiet your mind to truly hear someone else, you’re practicing the very skill needed to hear yourself clearly. The mental stillness required for deep listening becomes a pathway to self-understanding.

Try this today: in your next conversation, take a deep breath and intentionally slow down. Notice when your mind starts forming responses before they’ve finished speaking. Gently return to simply being with their words. This same practice of quieting the noise helps us recognize our own inner wisdom when we need it most.

The gift of your complete attention is precious—both to others and to yourself.

#DeepListening #ActiveListening #InnerVoice #BeStill #MindfulConnections #ListenToUnderstand #MentalStillness #PresentMoment #ConsciousConversation #SelfAwareness #MindfulListening #AuthenticConnection #SlowDown #QuietTheMind #ListeningSkills #RelationshipWisdom #EmotionalIntelligence #MindfulCommunication #SoulfulListening #InnerWisdom
amiethedatingcoach
amiethedatingcoach
•
Follow
When we truly become still and listen to understand others, something magical happens. By setting aside our mental chatter and focusing completely on what someone else is saying, we create a space of genuine connection. Active listening isn’t just waiting for your turn to speak. It’s being fully present—noticing not just their words, but their tone, their body language, what remains unsaid. When we listen this deeply to others, we’re actually strengthening our ability to tune into our own inner voice. Think about it: each time you quiet your mind to truly hear someone else, you’re practicing the very skill needed to hear yourself clearly. The mental stillness required for deep listening becomes a pathway to self-understanding. Try this today: in your next conversation, take a deep breath and intentionally slow down. Notice when your mind starts forming responses before they’ve finished speaking. Gently return to simply being with their words. This same practice of quieting the noise helps us recognize our own inner wisdom when we need it most. The gift of your complete attention is precious—both to others and to yourself. #DeepListening #ActiveListening #InnerVoice #BeStill #MindfulConnections #ListenToUnderstand #MentalStillness #PresentMoment #ConsciousConversation #SelfAwareness #MindfulListening #AuthenticConnection #SlowDown #QuietTheMind #ListeningSkills #RelationshipWisdom #EmotionalIntelligence #MindfulCommunication #SoulfulListening #InnerWisdom
2 weeks ago
View on Instagram |
4/5
Being Too Understanding? It’s Hurting You! 🥹

There’s a fine line between being compassionate and being a doormat. Learn when empathy goes too far!

#lackofboundaries #lackofrespect #peoplepleasing #letthem #mentalhealth #selfawareness #datingadvice
amiethedatingcoach
amiethedatingcoach
•
Follow
Being Too Understanding? It’s Hurting You! 🥹 There’s a fine line between being compassionate and being a doormat. Learn when empathy goes too far! #lackofboundaries #lackofrespect #peoplepleasing #letthem #mentalhealth #selfawareness #datingadvice
3 weeks ago
View on Instagram |
5/5
@amiethedatingcoach
  • HOME
  • ABOUT ME
  • WORK WITH ME
  • BLOG
  • DATING MEDIA INTERVIEWS
  • TESTIMONIALS

© 2025 - Amie Leadingham - Amie the Dating Coach, LLC - All Rights Reserved | LEGAL Site Powered by Pix & Hue.

ACCEPT
We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience. By continuing to browse the site, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies.
Cookie settings
Manage consent

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Non-necessary
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
SAVE & ACCEPT